Some good ideas, not sure about #5 or #4 but keep thinking, I can't I got 4 int.

maybe make dt harder to take too, whities been taking it every day. :P
have it so door is nobash, and when you enter guards lock behind you?

Gods just sit around like Elfy. They never incorporate ideas.

1 2 are kinda extreme, but yea make it tougher, 10 i kinda like imho groupsof +4 are for balrog and dragon only the random losing thing is kinda gay i dont agree with #7 you put all yuor time into that char you should get advantages i really like #4

I agree with everything except the multiclass one.
Multiclassing is one on the best features of mume, you don't pick your skills
at character creation. Plus, more people would be willing to solo if they
have bob, cure serious, etc... Doing away with multiclassing would INCREASE
hugegrouping, imho.

Fun to do Moria with huge delay, and loosing people in every room? NO

was just throwing out suggestions :)

hehe so funny zaber would complain about making big groups lag :) god what a joke

I Really like Number 5. It would be very cool being able to take over tbad, ooc and maybe other areas all over the map even.

Korf, its obvious you havent played anything else but darkie and that you suck at it. Play and learn ALL aspects of the game before you open your mouth again.

I don't agree with the no multiclass, I think that is a cool feature of
the game. I also think dt shouldn't be fortified, as when there were more
darkies on it used to be dangerous enough to try to take it as whities. But
I really think that something should be done about the hugegrouping. Perhaps
make it so that los and melee depended both on nubmer of people already engaged
and on number of sameside in your room not doing anything. Then you could
get melee even as the first hitter if you were hugegrouped. That would make it
much easier to run from a hugegroup for one. I really think that would
solve some of the hugegrouping problems, and would be the most important
change on that list, though grinder is pretty important too.

The really sucky thing about melee is that, as a solo char, you can attack
a group of 4 pukes and get no line of sight on spells!
As if any futher disadvantage was needed!

some ideas good but #7 not if atleast all others in work

and btw, i allready posted idea of conquring areas...(that eagle log...). Would be cool...

Don't forget - make wps visible again...:)

i think most of the ideas are great, but there is one thing bugging me
fucking moron Unknown complaining and don't even dare to post his name.

All nice points except 7 and 9 imho...

This is ok, except ooc and tbad ideas. And also was fun seeing that you chose Galadon for your call-lightning-thingy.

1,2,5,9,10

Are all very very bad suggestions only leads to more huge grouping if you need 30-40 pukes to raid instead of 10+

And dt is hard enugh as it is if darkies are around to defence it

those Ideas was good. not all but ok.

and rackhir, of course it should take like more then 8 pukes to clear noc. a group of 8 trolls wouldent be able to do bree and fnost. darkies need like ehum... 18+ to do bree and fnost. of course puke defense is more organized but hey darkies are more brutal and harder. i just cant understand how a hardon ranger is harder then an orc patrol. like 8 hardons would clean noc. while 8 darkie patrols would be slayed in bree and fnost.

gat damn soon its robinson and all

How bout add in the removal of portal and teleport. Those spells were obviously not in the books or the war would have lasted long enough for Gandalf to regen mana. And Fredde, please read the books and you'll know why rangers are tougher than orc patrols. Rangers KICKED major ass.

No changes need to be done in warrens.
But ob change on unarmed is necessary.

I dont even need to say more than than this "Log" is no more than a darkie
*WHINE*.
Korf grow up.
Darkies able to move west of neni is really not Tolkinish
Sure the dark riders came west but those where different times and u cant compare
any player with a nazgul. Also Orcs where alot more whimps only powering in numbers
not in strenght or skill.
Orcs ran when gandalf wielded the elf sword behind the crack....And that was a
tiny "puke" group.
Also problem with boosting defenses would be u meet even bigger groups raiding

Only Tolkinish thing i would miss would be bn warriors..
Alotto of us ppl miss fighting ppl like Bnwari :)
Other than that beside 3 + 8 i totally Disagree with u

Tempest, if you enjoy reading Lotr for the umpteenth time again rather than playing mume, please do so. And pay attention to the parts where the wizards, few as they were, equalled hundreds and thousands of warriors, etc.

Umm...i wouldn't call a group of 13 dwarves, one hobbit and gandalf a 'tiny' pukegroup...for me it looks more like raiding noc...after all, in 'the Hobbit' gandalf managed to whack gg without much trouble...lots of orcs died in caves but no pukes...:(

Arrrgh didn't even read all the comments

Whatever you do DO NOT make Noc stronger
I really wouldn't want Noc raids happen once per rl year

What you do to warrens is troll business.. but noc leave alone

I like some of the ideas. Several people have said that changing mume won't work, you have to change the people. I disagree. I think that in general, the people of mume (esp. those around a long time) don't like losing. As such, ppl feel like they need to get all the best eq in order to compete, which makes them twice as pissed off when they lose. Recent changes have made it too easy to lose playing darkie, therefore, a majority of those folks who don't like to lose are now playing puke. I don't know what the answer is. I personally like playing darkie even though I die more and it is more difficult. It just doesnt bother me as much to lose I guess.

about thorin and co. in 'hobbit'-they were pure newbies who got beaten by orcpatrol at high pass... They got some exp later to fight for erebor. So, they got exp for not only killing, but for clue and ideas, maneuvers (more like merp, ad&d). If all legends get their status for clue-ideas exp, there would be only few pukelegends and spamming assist in hugegroup would be pointless:)

btw, by tolkien some lvl60+ could solo balrog (gandalf did with efort of life...). There were dudes who nukes in solo dragon or 70 troll-mobs... Why not?

i generally play darkie cus i like having fun, and i dont find playing puke that much fun..
i like darkies cus they stick upp for eachother.. when a puke dies... none cares.. when someone is in deep shit.. none cares.. they start caring when they have something to gain.. like getting the chance to overkill a suntrapped troll, or finding a moveless orc in wswept, or porting in on an already inblocked bn with 5 ppl..

first of all, dont let unknowns bother ya darkwind, just dont read whatever
comments they post if name is unknown, cause it's usually stupid.
this is not a whine log evan, i just see alot of players leaving and was
trying to throw out a suggestion to stop this trend. mebbe not all ideas
were good, that's why i didnt put on the idea board, and that's why i
put 'NOT A REAL LOG', so people wouldn't flame me too much, cause
that gets old and boring to scroll down a list of comments that are all flames.

OK, lets make MUME more Tolkienish:
1)Hardons roam all across arda, but are fewer in numbers.
2)Elves should be able to kill 10+ legend orcs solo.
3)Big armies of the west move around all the time.
4)Hobbits can disguise themselves as orcs/trolls/bns.
5)A dragon can be killed with one arrow.
Etc, etc...
How many darkies would want to play then?

a clueless newbie-name was correct-all i hear is whine. If any comments, post with name and discuss. Btw, i didn't say with one arrow like bard of long lake. Also, hard-ones are really too strong and track freaking fast. Also, how many darkies said that will play now?? check out, was like 30 darkies today...*clueless*

All the gods do NOT sit around like elfy. I spent hours last night cleaning up justice messes calming spammers etc. Show a little thankfulness now and again. My fingers hurt from typing so much.

Erm, some ppl should really read more of the books. Gandalf was no level 60 puke, he was a MAIA. Same way that all balrogs are maiar. I SERIOUSLY doubt that any mortal on arda could have killed a balrog at that time, though it had happened a couple of times before. To make a long story short, noldorin elves should be able to whack any other char on mume :)

Imo we should have ringwraiths in mume, like top 9 bns (exp-wise or wps maybe) would get nice rings from Sauron, and those would be more powerful than puke foci.

Ah, and i hope everyone remembers the battle of helm's deep. Where Legolas killed 41 orcs with his dagger and Gimli 42 with his axe, all in a single blow :) Ah and every now a then a pack of ent mobs should raid noc, like 10 willows or so :)

There were no mortal (using the term to include elves) casters in Tolkien... at least nothin like in mume. Also, mume spells are essentially all AD&D spells... they have nothing to do with Tolkien. Also, it'd be nice to finally see the One Ring imped. People have said that it would unbalance the game, but I think it could be done reasonably. Make it an artifact that gives something like +10 ob, +10 pb, shroud that doesn't dissipate when hit, +2 spell, and some spell save. Granted, it'd make one char rocking, but even the strongest chars die eventually. It could load somewhere on Gollum, and involve a very-muddled quest to acquire.

yea mara rocks :P and feagil balrogs were NOT maiar i dont think grini could be wrong but am pretty sure they not

I am to a maiar, i'm just corrupted a tad :)

I dont think it's very tolkienish that the higher level puke chars that are spose to be feared sit on ther ass in bree either and to scared to fight so your not tolkienish comments are of no use in fact most things in game aren't tolkienish at least a lot of em

I like the nazgul idea. I don't think the 9 rings should be more powerful
than a whitie focus, as there were elf lords that could ride openly against
multiple of the 9. Rather, I think that something commensurate in power
should be granted, like the same spell speed and mana drop, as well as the
effects of a copper. And, the bn with the ring could still make a normal
unfocused attack staff to add to that. On an unrelated note, I think that the
ranger response to a multiple darkie group is just fine, but that truly
solo darkies shouldn't be chased by the rangers as much. Hit and chased for a
single zone or two if they are truly solo.

11. Remove the *Experienced Players Only* for the forces of the Dark Lord...

I vote for 3,4,6,8,9,10 :)

Really, if you read LotR, its pretty clear that Gandalf used control weather
and call lightning on weathertop, that the Witch King used darkness and break
door at Minas Tirith, and Gandalf used create light on Caradhras, etc etc

So there are spells in LotR

3, 4, 5 and 6 has my support.

Johannes said it best so far.

The only ideas up there that doesn't stink of newbie are #4 and #10.

In LotR, high level characters were actually very uncommon in Bree. Go figure.

...and I would write about the changes I think need to be made to MUME if it wasn't for 2 things. 1st, I'm at work and can't log on to MUME, but -do- have access to the Net, so I can write here. And 2nd, I've often written ideas both on the idea board and on the common boards, and have rarely if ever received any feedback or some indication that anyone has ever read them.

Was maybe uncorrect, sorry... About books..hehe, well has been reading tolkien when was some 12 years old (so over TEN years ago,wooh=P). Hobbit, lotr, silm... Well, at MERP(middle-earth roleplaying) was balrog lvl60 maia and gandalf kinda same... Yes, only powerful chars had in lotr spells (saruman, gandalf nazgul). Rings should be, not some hugegrps... And at bree i have sat only when awfully lagged or decaynig. And also there wouldn't be so much highlvl chars at bree when not so much hugegrps... But up some 'tolkien-ideas board' what also makes ideas someday to reality!? And nazgul-quest is allready in work :) check out... (Must give credit marajade and thnx for help:) And if my ideas are not correct-sry...